
Charlton, Campbell and the Curious Case of Nathan Jones: An Opposition View
Nathan Jones may arrive at Vicarage Road expecting pantomime hostility, but Charlton supporters have learned to enjoy the spectacle. After a late equaliser at Burnley, he went “bounding down the touchline” before hanging from the dugout “as if he was doing pull-ups”, his legs pedalling an imaginary bike. At Watford, though, even that performance may struggle to divert attention from the directors’ box.
There are certain things you can rely upon in the Championship. The league table will make absolutely no sense, the team that looks like world-beaters one week will resemble a Sunday morning pub side the next, and somebody somewhere will tell you that you cannot judge the table until ten games have been played.

Well, we've played ten games. I rather wish we hadn't.
With Charlton Athletic preparing to visit Vicarage Road, I caught up with Louis from Charlton Live, a man who had only returned from Burnley two and a half hours before our conversation. That's dedication to the cause, although having spent the night watching Charlton rescue a last-minute draw, I suspect he was running on adrenaline, caffeine and the peculiar optimism that only a late equaliser can produce.
For Watford supporters, optimism is currently a rather more complicated commodity.
Three Wins, Seven Without, and a League Table That Makes No Sense
Charlton's return to the Championship began with three consecutive victories. Naturally, having established that winning football matches was an enjoyable pastime, they promptly stopped doing it.
"It's been a really strange season for us," Louis admitted.
"We did front-load all our wins at the start of the season. Won our first three and then haven't won since then. So people are sort of a bit unsure how to feel."
That is quite a predicament. Charlton haven't been winning, but they haven't been losing particularly often either. Their mid-table position offers reasonable reassurance, even if their recent form suggests they have temporarily misplaced the instruction manual.
"There's some building blocks there. There's some things that we were bad at last season which we're still bad at, which I think overall has been scoring enough goals."
Defensively, Charlton have traditionally been built on solidity, but that particular foundation has developed a few cracks.
"We've conceded too many goals in our recent away games. Nine in the last three, which is obviously a problem when we've been a side that's been built on clean sheets."
Nine goals in three away games?
Luxury.
Watford had just conceded five at Cardiff, following a four-goal defeat against Burnley. When opposition supporters start expressing concern about their defensive record, it's rather like someone complaining about a dripping tap while you're standing in the remains of your flooded kitchen on the submerged Titanic!
Louis remained relatively philosophical.
"We've got enough points to be mid-table at the moment, which if we can keep that up we'll be fine."
A modest ambition, perhaps, but one which Watford supporters might currently regard with considerable envy.
Nathan Jones: Football Manager, Gymnast and Pantomime Villain
Of course, any discussion involving Charlton and Watford must eventually arrive at Nathan Jones.
For Watford supporters, Jones's Luton connections guarantee him a reception that will probably not involve flowers or a commemorative plaque.
Yet there is a fascinating distinction between watching Nathan Jones manage your club and watching him manage somebody else's. Louis believes most Charlton supporters remain behind their manager, although there are questions about the football.
"I still think most people are supportive, you know, and have a realistic view of where we need to be. But also there is a little bit about the style of play and whether we're a great watch."
Some supporters want entertainment. Others want results. Louis knows which camp he occupies.
"I'll probably put myself in the results bracket. As long as we're getting enough points to stay up, then I don't really care."
And then there's the entertainment Nathan Jones provides entirely independently of the football.

Charlton's late equaliser at Burnley produced a celebration that sounds less like a football manager expressing delight and more like an audition for Britain's Got Talent.
"He was off, bounding down the touchline and then hanging off the dugout as if he was doing pull-ups, and his little legs were going as if he was riding an imaginary bike."
It is an extraordinary mental picture - Louis had even asked Jones about it afterwards.
"He said that someone had been giving him sort of unrighteous abuse in the bit behind the dugout, which I believe happens every week anyway." Apparently, Jones had decided to return the compliment.
"Most of the fans, if not all of the fans, do quite enjoy that sort of pantomime side to it as well when he's your manager." And, rather painfully, I found myself agreeing.
If supporters give a manager abuse, they cannot reasonably complain when he gives a little back. Even if his chosen response involves hanging off a dugout like a particularly excitable twat that he is.
At Vicarage Road, however, Nathan Jones might discover that much of the crowd's attention is directed elsewhere.
With supporters increasingly angry about the direction of Watford Football Club, the directors' box could attract rather more attention than the technical area.
Which, given Nathan Jones's capacity for attracting attention, is quite an achievement.
Lyndon Dykes, Millwall and the Business of Replacing Goals
One departure that caught my eye was Lyndon Dykes.
The Scottish international had appeared a useful addition to Charlton's attack last season, so his subsequent move to Millwall seemed an interesting development. Had Charlton lost an important player? Was there resentment about his destination?
Not particularly, according to Louis.
"He only ever came in on a short-term deal. People liked what he provided in the first, particularly the first part of his time with Charlton."
His influence had apparently diminished towards the end of the campaign.
"I think towards the end of the season, it sort of waned a little bit when perhaps he had the World Cup with Scotland in mind."
And the move across south-east London wasn't viewed as an act of treachery.
"He wasn't quite around long enough for him to have gone to Millwall to be a massive story or, my God, he's betrayed us and gone to the other part of south-east London."
Charlton have since brought in different attacking options, including the returning Karlan Grant, while Miles Leaburn has assumed much of the physical centre-forward responsibility.
But there is a problem.
"He's doing all of the physical striker attributes apart from scoring the goals, which is the one thing that you have to say Lyndon did."
Football does have an irritating habit of insisting that strikers occasionally put the ball in the net. Dykes, Louis recalled, had actually offered that additional quality.
"He did pop up with maybe three or four goals in the second half of last season, and better finishes than I think we'd expect from Lyndon Dykes."
Sometimes the difference between League One and Championship football isn't spectacular. It's simply having players who can turn a half-chance into a goal.
A Little Bit of the 1990s
Karlan Grant's return to Charlton also provided an opportunity for some nostalgia.
Grant came through the Charlton academy before eventually moving to Huddersfield, and Louis remembers the moment when his potential began translating into performances.
"We had a couple of years where he was here and there, and you're thinking, oh, it's not going to happen for him."
Then came a successful loan spell at Crawley, followed by a breakthrough back at Charlton.
"He came back the next year and looked brilliant. And that led to Huddersfield spending some money on him." His return has been mixed, but he has contributed goals.
For those of us who remember Watford and Charlton seemingly playing each other every other fortnight during the 1990s, the combination of Grant and Leaburn carries a certain nostalgic appeal.
With Carl Leaburn having been such a familiar figure in those encounters, the prospect of another Leaburn and another Grant (no relation of Kim Grant I was informed) in Charlton colours feels like someone has discovered a forgotten fixture list behind a cupboard.
All we need now is Oasis to reform. Oh, hang on.

Tyreece Campbell: From Marmite to Main Man
Perhaps the most encouraging development for Charlton has been Tyreece Campbell.
I mentioned him to Louis during our previous conversation, having been impressed by the sort of player who catches the eye immediately: quick, direct and capable of making defenders question their career choices.
Last season, though, he was frustratingly inconsistent.
"He was the most sort of Marmite player for Charlton fans," Louis explained. "Everyone could see he had that something in his locker to provide a flash of excitement and drive and pace and trickery out wide. But where were the goals and where were the assists?"
This season, apparently, he's found them.
"I really think it's finally clicked for him."
Campbell had already scored five league goals at the time of our conversation, surpassing his previous season's total of three, and had also opened his international account for Jamaica.
"He's plundering both of them," Louis said of the goals and assists. But there remains a degree of dependence upon him.
"He's still certainly our best attacking player, and the fact he's added goals is the reason that we're currently, what, twelfth or whatever it is at time of recording, and not a lot further down the league table."
Charlton may have broadened their attacking options, but Campbell remains the player most likely to make something happen.
For Watford, whose defensive organisation has recently resembled an unattended supermarket trolley rolling downhill, that is not especially comforting.
Three at the Back, and Back to Basics
Nathan Jones spent much of the summer talking about evolution.
Having relied heavily upon a back three last season, Charlton began the campaign attempting to become more comfortable in possession and more adventurous going forward.
The results have been mixed.
Against Bristol City, a promising start in a 4-2-3-1 gave way to a lengthy spell under pressure.
Then Jones changed formation. "He switched it to a back three, and we completely nullified Bristol City," Louis recalled. Charlton even began creating opportunities of their own. So it wasn't particularly surprising when Jones returned to the system at Burnley.
"Burnley didn't have many clear-cut chances yesterday, so in that regard it sort of worked."
Unfortunately, Charlton still conceded twice.
"We still gave away two poor goals, particularly the second one. I thought we stood off the chap way too much and let him drive into the box and have a shot." The tactical structure might have improved, but individual defending remained problematic.
"We conceded two goals by being stupid and not doing our defensive work despite the structure being a bit better."
It's a sentence that Watford supporters could probably have embroidered onto a cushion.
Louis suspects Jones is increasingly concerned about recovering the defensive reliability that helped Charlton secure promotion.
"We're trying to become a more free-flowing, goalscoring side. It hasn't quite clicked."
Whether Charlton continue with three central defenders at Vicarage Road remains to be seen as the game at Burnley was the first time it was tried all season, but the system clearly offers Jones some reassurance.
Danny McNamara and the Value of Knowing Your Job
Another player of interest was Danny McNamara, the former Millwall full-back who had previously been heavily linked with Watford.
His arrival at Charlton was initially expected to provide competition rather than an automatic starting place. Then Kayne Ramsay suffered an injury.
"Danny's played a lot more than people expected," Louis explained.
And his contribution has illustrated something that supporters of recently promoted clubs often discover: Championship experience matters.
"When you see someone who's actually played 150 games in the Championship coming to your side, even if they're not the best Championship player, you see a difference."
"It's remarkable. You can just see a step up in quality, even if they're just a solid Championship player."
McNamara's Millwall background might once have made him an unlikely favourite at The Valley, particularly given his previous involvement in an argument with a Charlton supporter.
But football has a way of rearranging loyalties.
"He's been very professional and done his job and done it well."
Sometimes that is precisely what a football club needs.
At Watford, where the defence has recently struggled to demonstrate the basic concept of standing between an opponent and the goal, a dependable fit Championship full-back sounds almost exotic.
The Championship's Biggest Surprise? Cardiff
When I asked Louis which Championship opponents had impressed him most, his answer was particularly uncomfortable.
Cardiff City.
Yes, that Cardiff City.
The same Cardiff who had just dismantled Watford 5–1.
"They absolutely battered us," Louis admitted. "I thought they were brilliant. Moylan was brilliant for them."
He believed Cardiff had been unfortunate not to have accumulated more points earlier in the season.
"You speak to Cardiff fans and they were like, even if you just go for the eye test, we should have got three or four wins already and we've had none."
And Charlton's defeat to them had left a lasting impression.
"They should have scored more goals against us than they did."
He also felt West Ham, whom Charlton had beaten earlier in the season, were beginning to understand the particular demands of Championship football.
"They didn't really understand the mechanics of Championship football and the pace."
Louis expects them to improve as the campaign progresses.
But perhaps the most alarming assessment concerned Burnley.
"I thought Burnley were pretty crap last night. Defensively they looked awful and their goalkeeper is an absolute joke."
He wasn't finished. "He was rubbish. Like genuinely I felt offended that he was playing in the Championship." This was the same Burnley side that had recently put four past Watford.
There are moments when interviewing an opposition supporter becomes less an exercise in gathering intelligence and more an opportunity to discover entirely new depths of despair.
This was one of them.
Charlton arrive with three early victories, seven subsequent games without a win, an increasingly influential Tyreece Campbell, a manager capable of performing impromptu gymnastics and a supporter base broadly satisfied with the prospect of Championship survival.
Watford, meanwhile, arrive with a defensive record that makes the phrase glass jaw sound positively flattering, supporters furious with the club's ownership and the uneasy suspicion that simply changing the manager will resolve very little.
On paper, perhaps, it's a perfectly ordinary Championship fixture.
But as Louis and I established over twenty minutes, there is nothing particularly ordinary about either club's season.
And should Nathan Jones end up hanging from the Vicarage Road dugout after another late winner, I suspect the least of Watford's problems will be his imaginary bicycle.













