← Preview archive
DNSYECharlton Athletic
PREVIEW
Charlton Athletic
14 OCTOBER 2026
DO NOT SCRATCH YOUR EYES
THE DNSYE ELECTRONIC FANZINE

NATHAN JONES YOU'VE NOT BEEN GONE LONG ENOUGH!!

Malky tell us how GT supported him as Watford Manager plus Troys 1 in 10 managers

This issue

01Charlton, Campbell and the Curious Case of Nathan Jones: An Opposition ViewNathan Jones may arrive at Vicarage Road expecting pantomime hostility, but Charlton supporters have learned to enjoy the spectacle. After a late equaliser at Burnley, he went “bounding down the touchline” before hanging from the dugout “as if he was doing pull-ups”, his legs pedalling an imaginary bike. At Watford, though, even that performance may struggle to divert attention from the directors’ box.02TROY DEENEY ONE IN TEN: MANAGERSTroy was charged with giving the shortest possible comment on some of his managers at Watford...some of his choices were quite interesting!03Detached from reality - Burnley and everything afterPete reflects on how his season has felt slightly out of kilter from the real world and therefore why Burnley and the official podcast comments seem perfectly in keeping with things!04Malky MacKay Special Cleverley and GTMalky recalls who helped him when he started as a manager.
PREVIEW
HEADER DESIGN
← THIS ISSUE
ARTICLE 1 OF 4

Charlton, Campbell and the Curious Case of Nathan Jones: An Opposition View

Nathan Jones may arrive at Vicarage Road expecting pantomime hostility, but Charlton supporters have learned to enjoy the spectacle. After a late equaliser at Burnley, he went “bounding down the touchline” before hanging from the dugout “as if he was doing pull-ups”, his legs pedalling an imaginary bike. At Watford, though, even that performance may struggle to divert attention from the directors’ box.

There are certain things you can rely upon in the Championship. The league table will make absolutely no sense, the team that looks like world-beaters one week will resemble a Sunday morning pub side the next, and somebody somewhere will tell you that you cannot judge the table until ten games have been played.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
Goalhanger

Well, we've played ten games. I rather wish we hadn't.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

With Charlton Athletic preparing to visit Vicarage Road, I caught up with Louis from Charlton Live, a man who had only returned from Burnley two and a half hours before our conversation. That's dedication to the cause, although having spent the night watching Charlton rescue a last-minute draw, I suspect he was running on adrenaline, caffeine and the peculiar optimism that only a late equaliser can produce.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

For Watford supporters, optimism is currently a rather more complicated commodity.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Three Wins, Seven Without, and a League Table That Makes No Sense

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Charlton's return to the Championship began with three consecutive victories. Naturally, having established that winning football matches was an enjoyable pastime, they promptly stopped doing it.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"It's been a really strange season for us," Louis admitted.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"We did front-load all our wins at the start of the season. Won our first three and then haven't won since then. So people are sort of a bit unsure how to feel."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

That is quite a predicament. Charlton haven't been winning, but they haven't been losing particularly often either. Their mid-table position offers reasonable reassurance, even if their recent form suggests they have temporarily misplaced the instruction manual.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"There's some building blocks there. There's some things that we were bad at last season which we're still bad at, which I think overall has been scoring enough goals."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Defensively, Charlton have traditionally been built on solidity, but that particular foundation has developed a few cracks.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"We've conceded too many goals in our recent away games. Nine in the last three, which is obviously a problem when we've been a side that's been built on clean sheets."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Nine goals in three away games?

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Luxury.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Watford had just conceded five at Cardiff, following a four-goal defeat against Burnley. When opposition supporters start expressing concern about their defensive record, it's rather like someone complaining about a dripping tap while you're standing in the remains of your flooded kitchen on the submerged Titanic!

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Louis remained relatively philosophical.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"We've got enough points to be mid-table at the moment, which if we can keep that up we'll be fine."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

A modest ambition, perhaps, but one which Watford supporters might currently regard with considerable envy.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Nathan Jones: Football Manager, Gymnast and Pantomime Villain

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Of course, any discussion involving Charlton and Watford must eventually arrive at Nathan Jones.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

For Watford supporters, Jones's Luton connections guarantee him a reception that will probably not involve flowers or a commemorative plaque.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Yet there is a fascinating distinction between watching Nathan Jones manage your club and watching him manage somebody else's. Louis believes most Charlton supporters remain behind their manager, although there are questions about the football.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"I still think most people are supportive, you know, and have a realistic view of where we need to be. But also there is a little bit about the style of play and whether we're a great watch."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Some supporters want entertainment. Others want results. Louis knows which camp he occupies.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"I'll probably put myself in the results bracket. As long as we're getting enough points to stay up, then I don't really care."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

And then there's the entertainment Nathan Jones provides entirely independently of the football.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
Never quiet and reserved on the touchline

Charlton's late equaliser at Burnley produced a celebration that sounds less like a football manager expressing delight and more like an audition for Britain's Got Talent.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He was off, bounding down the touchline and then hanging off the dugout as if he was doing pull-ups, and his little legs were going as if he was riding an imaginary bike."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

It is an extraordinary mental picture - Louis had even asked Jones about it afterwards.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He said that someone had been giving him sort of unrighteous abuse in the bit behind the dugout, which I believe happens every week anyway." Apparently, Jones had decided to return the compliment.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"Most of the fans, if not all of the fans, do quite enjoy that sort of pantomime side to it as well when he's your manager." And, rather painfully, I found myself agreeing.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

If supporters give a manager abuse, they cannot reasonably complain when he gives a little back. Even if his chosen response involves hanging off a dugout like a particularly excitable twat that he is.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

At Vicarage Road, however, Nathan Jones might discover that much of the crowd's attention is directed elsewhere.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

With supporters increasingly angry about the direction of Watford Football Club, the directors' box could attract rather more attention than the technical area.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Which, given Nathan Jones's capacity for attracting attention, is quite an achievement.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Lyndon Dykes, Millwall and the Business of Replacing Goals

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

One departure that caught my eye was Lyndon Dykes.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The Scottish international had appeared a useful addition to Charlton's attack last season, so his subsequent move to Millwall seemed an interesting development. Had Charlton lost an important player? Was there resentment about his destination?

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Not particularly, according to Louis.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He only ever came in on a short-term deal. People liked what he provided in the first, particularly the first part of his time with Charlton."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

His influence had apparently diminished towards the end of the campaign.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"I think towards the end of the season, it sort of waned a little bit when perhaps he had the World Cup with Scotland in mind."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

And the move across south-east London wasn't viewed as an act of treachery.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He wasn't quite around long enough for him to have gone to Millwall to be a massive story or, my God, he's betrayed us and gone to the other part of south-east London."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Charlton have since brought in different attacking options, including the returning Karlan Grant, while Miles Leaburn has assumed much of the physical centre-forward responsibility.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

But there is a problem.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He's doing all of the physical striker attributes apart from scoring the goals, which is the one thing that you have to say Lyndon did."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Football does have an irritating habit of insisting that strikers occasionally put the ball in the net. Dykes, Louis recalled, had actually offered that additional quality.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He did pop up with maybe three or four goals in the second half of last season, and better finishes than I think we'd expect from Lyndon Dykes."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Sometimes the difference between League One and Championship football isn't spectacular. It's simply having players who can turn a half-chance into a goal.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

A Little Bit of the 1990s

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Karlan Grant's return to Charlton also provided an opportunity for some nostalgia.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Grant came through the Charlton academy before eventually moving to Huddersfield, and Louis remembers the moment when his potential began translating into performances.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"We had a couple of years where he was here and there, and you're thinking, oh, it's not going to happen for him."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Then came a successful loan spell at Crawley, followed by a breakthrough back at Charlton.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He came back the next year and looked brilliant. And that led to Huddersfield spending some money on him." His return has been mixed, but he has contributed goals.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

For those of us who remember Watford and Charlton seemingly playing each other every other fortnight during the 1990s, the combination of Grant and Leaburn carries a certain nostalgic appeal.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

With Carl Leaburn having been such a familiar figure in those encounters, the prospect of another Leaburn and another Grant (no relation of Kim Grant I was informed) in Charlton colours feels like someone has discovered a forgotten fixture list behind a cupboard.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

All we need now is Oasis to reform. Oh, hang on.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
Tyreece Campbell & Karlan Grant

Tyreece Campbell: From Marmite to Main Man

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Perhaps the most encouraging development for Charlton has been Tyreece Campbell.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

I mentioned him to Louis during our previous conversation, having been impressed by the sort of player who catches the eye immediately: quick, direct and capable of making defenders question their career choices.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Last season, though, he was frustratingly inconsistent.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He was the most sort of Marmite player for Charlton fans," Louis explained. "Everyone could see he had that something in his locker to provide a flash of excitement and drive and pace and trickery out wide. But where were the goals and where were the assists?"

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

This season, apparently, he's found them.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"I really think it's finally clicked for him."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Campbell had already scored five league goals at the time of our conversation, surpassing his previous season's total of three, and had also opened his international account for Jamaica.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He's plundering both of them," Louis said of the goals and assists. But there remains a degree of dependence upon him.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He's still certainly our best attacking player, and the fact he's added goals is the reason that we're currently, what, twelfth or whatever it is at time of recording, and not a lot further down the league table."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Charlton may have broadened their attacking options, but Campbell remains the player most likely to make something happen.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

For Watford, whose defensive organisation has recently resembled an unattended supermarket trolley rolling downhill, that is not especially comforting.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Three at the Back, and Back to Basics

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Nathan Jones spent much of the summer talking about evolution.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Having relied heavily upon a back three last season, Charlton began the campaign attempting to become more comfortable in possession and more adventurous going forward.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The results have been mixed.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Against Bristol City, a promising start in a 4-2-3-1 gave way to a lengthy spell under pressure.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Then Jones changed formation. "He switched it to a back three, and we completely nullified Bristol City," Louis recalled. Charlton even began creating opportunities of their own. So it wasn't particularly surprising when Jones returned to the system at Burnley.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"Burnley didn't have many clear-cut chances yesterday, so in that regard it sort of worked."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Unfortunately, Charlton still conceded twice.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"We still gave away two poor goals, particularly the second one. I thought we stood off the chap way too much and let him drive into the box and have a shot." The tactical structure might have improved, but individual defending remained problematic.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"We conceded two goals by being stupid and not doing our defensive work despite the structure being a bit better."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

It's a sentence that Watford supporters could probably have embroidered onto a cushion.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Louis suspects Jones is increasingly concerned about recovering the defensive reliability that helped Charlton secure promotion.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"We're trying to become a more free-flowing, goalscoring side. It hasn't quite clicked."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Whether Charlton continue with three central defenders at Vicarage Road remains to be seen as the game at Burnley was the first time it was tried all season, but the system clearly offers Jones some reassurance.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Danny McNamara and the Value of Knowing Your Job

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Another player of interest was Danny McNamara, the former Millwall full-back who had previously been heavily linked with Watford.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

His arrival at Charlton was initially expected to provide competition rather than an automatic starting place. Then Kayne Ramsay suffered an injury.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"Danny's played a lot more than people expected," Louis explained.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

And his contribution has illustrated something that supporters of recently promoted clubs often discover: Championship experience matters.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"When you see someone who's actually played 150 games in the Championship coming to your side, even if they're not the best Championship player, you see a difference."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"It's remarkable. You can just see a step up in quality, even if they're just a solid Championship player."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

McNamara's Millwall background might once have made him an unlikely favourite at The Valley, particularly given his previous involvement in an argument with a Charlton supporter.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

But football has a way of rearranging loyalties.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"He's been very professional and done his job and done it well."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Sometimes that is precisely what a football club needs.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

At Watford, where the defence has recently struggled to demonstrate the basic concept of standing between an opponent and the goal, a dependable fit Championship full-back sounds almost exotic.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The Championship's Biggest Surprise? Cardiff

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

When I asked Louis which Championship opponents had impressed him most, his answer was particularly uncomfortable.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Cardiff City.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Yes, that Cardiff City.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The same Cardiff who had just dismantled Watford 5–1.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"They absolutely battered us," Louis admitted. "I thought they were brilliant. Moylan was brilliant for them."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

He believed Cardiff had been unfortunate not to have accumulated more points earlier in the season.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"You speak to Cardiff fans and they were like, even if you just go for the eye test, we should have got three or four wins already and we've had none."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

And Charlton's defeat to them had left a lasting impression.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"They should have scored more goals against us than they did."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

He also felt West Ham, whom Charlton had beaten earlier in the season, were beginning to understand the particular demands of Championship football.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"They didn't really understand the mechanics of Championship football and the pace."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Louis expects them to improve as the campaign progresses.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

But perhaps the most alarming assessment concerned Burnley.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

"I thought Burnley were pretty crap last night. Defensively they looked awful and their goalkeeper is an absolute joke."

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

He wasn't finished. "He was rubbish. Like genuinely I felt offended that he was playing in the Championship." This was the same Burnley side that had recently put four past Watford.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

There are moments when interviewing an opposition supporter becomes less an exercise in gathering intelligence and more an opportunity to discover entirely new depths of despair.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

This was one of them.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Charlton arrive with three early victories, seven subsequent games without a win, an increasingly influential Tyreece Campbell, a manager capable of performing impromptu gymnastics and a supporter base broadly satisfied with the prospect of Championship survival.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Watford, meanwhile, arrive with a defensive record that makes the phrase glass jaw sound positively flattering, supporters furious with the club's ownership and the uneasy suspicion that simply changing the manager will resolve very little.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

On paper, perhaps, it's a perfectly ordinary Championship fixture.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

But as Louis and I established over twenty minutes, there is nothing particularly ordinary about either club's season.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

And should Nathan Jones end up hanging from the Vicarage Road dugout after another late winner, I suspect the least of Watford's problems will be his imaginary bicycle.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
PREVIEW
HEADER DESIGN
← THIS ISSUE
ARTICLE 2 OF 4

TROY DEENEY ONE IN TEN: MANAGERS

Troy was charged with giving the shortest possible comment on some of his managers at Watford...some of his choices were quite interesting!

DNSYE’s One in Ten is often an excuse to play the old Birmingahm musical royalty UB40 track and who better to take part than Birmingham football Royalty as far Hornets are concerned

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Putting Troy Deeney through it creates an obvious problem: there are rather a lot of managers.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

So DNSYE removes the scores and keeps the important bit:ONE WORD REVIEW.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“One word. It can be teapot. It doesn’t matter.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Troy begins with Malky Mackay.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“Hungry.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Not metaphorically. Troy remembers Mackay’s table being positioned near the serving area in the canteen and seemingly seeing him eating every time he queued for food. Better still, Mackay would give the young Deeney grief about what he was eating while apparently permanently eating himself.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“I’m just trying to eat.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Sean Dyche requires rather less thought.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“Legend.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

This one is not a joke. Troy credits Dyche with making him “a man in football”. He had arrived at Watford after a rapid rise and admits that professionalism away from training had not caught up. Dyche gave him standards, challenged him and became something approaching a father figure.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Next: Gianfranco Zola.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
No caption

“Magician.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Again, the word carries real weight. Troy says Zola was the first person who actually taught him how to be a goalscorer. The lessons were technical and specific: stop trying to destroy the ball, shorten the steps, improve the balance, pass finishes into the goal. Repetition followed until the work became instinct.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Then comes Beppe Sannino.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Troy smiles. Looks away.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
No caption

“Mental.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

That opens the door to Sannino’s first training session. The squad, Troy recalls, had apparently not “earned the right” to use the good pitches, so they trained on a rougher surface instead. A session expected to last around an hour stretched towards three. Day one did not exactly produce universal devotion.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Watford’s managerial carousel means Oscar Garcia and Billy McKinlay barely have time to qualify for the game before the conversation moves on. The feature itself starts becoming a history of the club’s changing eras.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

When Premier League life arrives, Quique Sánchez Flores gets perhaps the least tactical one-word assessment of the afternoon.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“Sexy.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

DNSYE accepts this immediately.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“He’s a good-looking man, wasn’t he?”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Troy agrees, before giving a much more substantial assessment. First time around, he thought Flores was very good. Troy returned for pre-season badly out of shape and remembers a manager who worked with him rather than simply punishing him. Instead of every extra session being anonymous time on a bike, Flores would sometimes jog with him and talk football.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The second spell was different. Troy says he told Flores that returning would be difficult because everyone would inevitably compare the sequel with the original.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“Second ones are never better than the first.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Marco Silva produces one of the more complicated answers.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“Brilliant.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

That might surprise anyone expecting Troy to judge solely by how the relationship ended. He does not. He describes Silva as bringing a level of detail and professionalism the squad had not previously experienced, upgrading fitness work and constantly thinking in terms of improving the team from one transfer window to the next.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG QUOTE
“That might surprise anyone expecting Troy to judge solely by how the relationship ended. He does not. He describes Silva as bringing a level of detail and professionalism the squad had not previously experienced, upgrading fitness work and constantly thinking in terms of improving the team from one transfer window to the next.”

But Troy also describes the breakdown around Everton as a collision of egos from which everybody suffered. His assessment therefore contains both things at once: an excellent coach and a situation handled badly.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Javi Gracia brings a different atmosphere.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“He was brilliant. Him and his team were great.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Troy remembers humility rather than ego. Gracia’s English was developing, but he was willing to be vulnerable enough to make mistakes in front of the group. The coaching was front-footed and detailed without the staff needing to establish themselves through confrontation.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“They were the bosses.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

They did not need to keep proving it.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Nigel Pearson gets the most emphatic review of the later years.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
No caption

“Nigel’s fucking brilliant, man. I love that man.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Pearson’s great trick, in Troy’s telling, was making Watford one club again. Staff from across the organisation were gathered together, including ownership, and told that survival would depend on everybody.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Treat the kit lady with the same respect as the owner. Grounds staff, office staff, players, coaches: one group.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

“All of us combined, all of us together.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

And eventually the conversation reaches Vladimir Ivic, where One in Ten stops being quite so playful.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Troy describes repeatedly asking Ivic whether there was a problem between them and being told there was not. After a match in which Troy did not play, he heard the manager’s public comments while driving home and believed he was being blamed. The episode exploded, the club publicly backed Troy and, in his view, managed to create an even bigger impression that the player held too much power.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

It is an appropriately messy end to a feature about a remarkably messy managerial era.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

What makes Troy’s answers interesting is that they are rarely simple verdicts. He can love a manager who tried to sell him. He can call another brilliant while explaining why the relationship around him collapsed. He can remember tactical detail and still reduce somebody else to the fact that he always seemed to be eating.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Which is exactly why One in Ten works.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Football history is usually tidied up afterwards into appointments, formations, results and sackings.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The player remembers who made him better.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Who made him laugh.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Who drove him mad.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

And, occasionally, who had already beaten him to the canteen.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
PREVIEW
HEADER DESIGN
← THIS ISSUE
ARTICLE 3 OF 4

Detached from reality - Burnley and everything after

Pete reflects on how his season has felt slightly out of kilter from the real world and therefore why Burnley and the official podcast comments seem perfectly in keeping with things!

Due to personal circumstances, I am watching things go on at Watford from a distance so far this season. Whilst less than three miles away from the ground, the only match I have been able to attend was the home game against West Ham.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

It’s a peculiar type of detachment – an experience far less rich than attending matches – and I appreciate those who were in attendance against Burnley will not necessarily feel that their experience was improved by attending. It’s not the games so much, I can kick every ball from the sofa as I have done now for away games for many years. It’s the pre match coming together that is missing and the experience is far more sterile without it.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

As during COVID every match starts and more or less ends with the game itself – it’s only hosting the “Post Match Phone In” that allows me to elongate the experience after the final whistle.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The anticipation, the gradual approach to kick off is not felt as a crescendo. The hubbub of having a beer in the bunker or the fan zone or on the concourse is not felt. The collective level of expectation be it hope or desperation isn’t shared in the conversations with friends or felt in the atmosphere.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The atmosphere at the ground, even when it is flat is something tangible – an emotional barometer of expectation or lack thereof. Whatever the fan temperature is, it is like the weather – it’s something to talk about be it good or bad. It is a shared experience to be in the same location and wishing for the same outcome with thousands of others – be they friends or strangers.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
No caption

I don’t regret not being there though, because what I am doing now is, in this moment, far more important. To me it’s not even a choice but it’s the temporary lack of home game attendance that I feel most keenly. I’m sure some others will find not attending games a positive thing – the frustration of watching “their” Watford retract on and off the pitch, withering slowly, might be felt perhaps less intensely – but I doubt for many that is the case.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

So instead of that regular emotional pulse check at the ground, I like many others am reliant on the internet (the TV these days is delivered via the internet after all). Whether its TV, social media, streaming or whatever, it is seen through someone else’s eyes. Be it the TV producer/editor, the journalist, the commentator, or other fans. It still feels like a pre-processed meal rather than a homemade nourishing experience by comparison.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Even with this detachment and other diversions, it has to be said that the Burnley game was simply appalling. The team did look imbalanced, and the bench once more was lobsided as our two left backs proclaimed as “fit” returned to the squad but not fit enough to start. Instead Coulibaly was shunted to left back and Mlacic played centrally alongside Pollock. On the right Traore returned fit enough to run forward into advanced positions when Watford had possession but not fit enough to get back when the back line surrendered the ball cheaply with an ill-advised pass from Mlacic to Kyprianou who was “not on his toes.” Even then as with all of the first three goals conceded we shot ourselves in the foot and failed to recover when the chance availed itself.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
No caption

The malaise at the wider club appears to have affected Mattie Pollock, it would surprise me had it not to be frank. He has been playing alongside Keben, whose penchant for dropping goal concession worthy clangers every game undoes much of the good he is potentially capable of. But “potentially” is doing a lot of heavy lifting in that sentence. Potential without realisation doesn’t help the results or the league table.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The tentative under hit pass into Kyprianou was indicative of a team who were scared to play forward from the back. Long forward passes into opposition laden areas tend to surrender possession at the best of times, let alone in a game when Kjerrumgaard acted like a toddler trying to hit a heavy weight prize fighter before giving it up as a bad lot, so instead we see safe lateral passes and shorter distances of advancement that encourage a Burnley press. In reality the backline is passing the responsibility more than it is passing the ball.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

In my experience timidity in the game can become contagious, in the same way that Kjeerumgaard doesn’t the hold the ball up, we stop playing the ball to or through him and suddenly we are playing with the equivalent of 10 men. The skittish backline and immobile midfield concede another two in the same nervous fashion and then in an act of either self-sabotage or managerial masterstroke – Dionisi removes Bravo and in doing so publicly gives up on this game and instead chooses to save his scant resources for Tuesday night at Cardiff.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

We see Boadu come on and wonder why in three weeks he has gained enough fitness to add only 30 minutes here to the 21 minutes he got at Bristol City. Whether or not Boadu succeeds or not at Watford, he at least has the appearance of someone with confidence in his own ability – the arrogance that most players need and Kjeerumgaard to apparently lacks currently.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Once again, the midfield looks light-weight and immobile, without Bove there to beat the tempo that others rise to, is flat and lifeless. Bove’s tenacity, aggression, and snappiness (if that’s even a word!!) have been sorely missed – his energy that emanated outward, beyond the midfield into the whole team in the early games of the season, vanished with his over eager challenge at West Bromwich.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
No caption

Bove is one of those Pozzo signings where the initial signing and his efforts last season beyond the cathartic goal against Wrexham, gave no indication of how vital he would be to the identity of the team. His enforced removal from the team has seen Watford dwindle in intensity. Like so many Watford recruits these days having to return after a long layoff and failing to get enough games to build strength and robustness, before breaking down again.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

At Bristol City Dionisi innovated as a man with only a few options is forced to – by playing Bravo in the central area of the pitch. The problem is whilst he was tenacious and tried hard – moving your second-best player to cover the loss of your best player is rarely a recipe for success but frankly Dionisi only has the ingredients for an omelette – as he has only a surplus of broken eggs currently to work with.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

This performance coming after the increasingly delusional official podcast was frustrating for those in attendance or like me watching remotely. Duxbury and Dowling spoke about Dionisi having one of the best squads in the division, having already proclaimed that fitness issues would be resolved by the international break.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

In the same episode they referred to the new signing Krepin Diatta – not deemed ready to start of course as an incredible signing – and this may well prove to be correct. However, they credited the signing of a player with his experience as being evidence of the “world class scouting network.” This is either ill-informed or outright stupidity. As stipulated in my article when Diatta signed for the club – his previous two transfers had involved a certain agent – a certain Mr Mogi Bayat. “World class scouting network” rings hollow.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The actions of Sir Elton John, Troy Deeney, Paul Robinson and of course Roy Moore following this game will add another interesting thread to the storyline of Pozzo era Watford and coupled with the Spanish Tax case previously covered here, commencing on 9th November, may mean that the next few chapters of the Watford story are very intense indeed.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Pete

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
PREVIEW
HEADER DESIGN
← THIS ISSUE
ARTICLE 4 OF 4

Malky MacKay Special Cleverley and GT

Malky recalls who helped him when he started as a manager.

# Malky MacKay Special

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
No caption

Malky MacKay’s time at Watford offers a lesson in patience, responsibility and the importance of allowing a manager to build something recognisably his own.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

At the heart of MacKay’s recollections was the support he received from Graham Taylor. The message from Taylor was that transforming a side could not happen immediately: “This is not going to be your team for three years because you’re going to have to take time for it to look like you.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
No caption

That was more than an appeal for patience. Taylor also made clear that responsibility for the appointment did not rest solely with the manager. As MacKay recalled it, Taylor told him: “If you’re gone in three years, then so will I be, because I’m going to be accountable for what we do.”

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

It revealed an approach to leadership based on shared accountability. Taylor was prepared to support the manager he had helped appoint, but also to stake his own position on that decision. In MacKay’s view, too many directors could make an appointment, dismiss the manager when difficulties arrived and then escape scrutiny themselves.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

That memory of Watford carried particular relevance during a discussion about Tom Cleverley and the value of giving a young manager time to learn. Cleverley’s relationship with the club is different, but there is a similar need for patience. He is still early in his managerial career, will inevitably make mistakes and has not always had the level of support some believe he deserves. MacKay’s experience under Taylor showed what could be possible when a manager was given room to develop alongside his team.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

MacKay’s subsequent work at Hibernian also provided a modern parallel. As technical director, he was part of a club that endured a difficult start under David Gray, a former Hibs player who remained popular with supporters. Gray’s position appeared uncertain after a long spell without a win, but Hibernian stayed with him and their form changed dramatically. That patience was rewarded as they climbed the table and defeated Celtic at Easter Road.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH
↕ DRAG IMAGE
No caption

The comparison was not presented as exact, but the underlying principle was familiar: clubs can benefit from resisting the impulse to make an immediate change when results become difficult. Both Gray and Cleverley had strong existing connections to their clubs, while MacKay’s story demonstrated the value of senior figures accepting responsibility and providing genuine backing.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

The discussion also considered whether MacKay could one day be suited to a technical director’s role at Watford. His knowledge of Scottish football, his Championship experience and his understanding of Watford were all seen as potential strengths. One view was that he could be particularly effective at Championship level, although there was more uncertainty over how that experience would translate to the Premier League.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

What stood out most, however, was not speculation over a future role. It was the philosophy MacKay absorbed during his time at Watford: appoint carefully, support properly and accept that building a team with the manager’s identity takes time.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH

Taylor’s commitment to MacKay went beyond public reassurance. He understood that the people making football decisions should be answerable for them too. In an era when managers can easily become the lone scapegoat, that sense of collective responsibility remains the most powerful theme from MacKay’s Watford story.

DROP IMAGE / QUOTE AFTER THIS PARAGRAPH