What happens when the questions come home?
In Granada, the arguments are being made in a courtroom. In Watford, they are being made in living rooms, pubs, supporters’ groups and wherever Hornets gather to worry about the future of their football club. The two conversations are not the same. An allegation about the tax treatment of player transfers in Spain is not evidence of misconduct at Watford. But it would be equally absurd to pretend that the man who owns Watford can stand trial over the running of another football club and that it has nothing to do with us.
For much of this week, we have tried to explain the Spanish proceedings: who is accused of what, why a three-judge panel rather than a jury is hearing the case, and how the prosecution and defence describe the transactions at Granada. The legal distinctions matter, particularly when an allegation is only an allegation. On a Sunday, though, perhaps the more uncomfortable question is what the whole affair says about football ownership, and how little supporters are sometimes permitted to know about the businesses to which their clubs belong.
There but for the grace of God go we. It is a phrase that works in more than one direction. Watford supporters can look at Granada and be grateful that this particular prosecution concerns events at another club. Granada had already been sold by the time Watford reached the Premier League, so their supporters cannot simply compare the subsequent fortunes of clubs still operating under common ownership. But they might now reasonably feel that Granada is being left to foot a greater share of the bill — through the uncertainty, financial exposure and potential consequences of decisions made during the Pozzo era — without having enjoyed the initial success that Watford and Udinese experienced. That is a question of perceived fairness, not a finding about how costs or benefits were actually distributed. Neither observation answers the question of whose interests were being served when money and players moved around the wider network.
The good years were real. So are the questions.
It is worth saying plainly that the Pozzo years at Watford were not an uninterrupted failure. The early recruitment, the rapid climb to the Premier League, five consecutive seasons in the top flight and the 2019 FA Cup final are not things supporters imagined. The model produced extraordinary moments. The names on the shirts, the away days and the memories belong to the club and its supporters, whatever anyone now thinks of the people who presided over them.
Scott Duxbury’s standing among many Watford supporters has hardly emerged unscathed from the past five years. Disappointing seasons, managerial upheaval, poor communication and a succession of unfortunate public pronouncements have steadily eroded the goodwill accumulated during the club’s earlier successes. His association with the Pozzo ownership is therefore not the sole threat to an otherwise untarnished reputation. It adds another uncomfortable dimension to a period in which confidence in the club’s leadership has already been badly tested.
Nor was the decline simply a successful project running out of fuel. Watford’s repeated changes of direction, squad rebuilds and concerns about the club’s financial position have left questions that cannot be explained away by reference to the Premier League years. The question is whether those responsible for both the rise and the fall have left Watford secure enough to withstand the next difficult chapter. Proceedings involving the owner elsewhere add uncertainty to a position already weakened by decisions made much closer to home.
Tevez, West Ham and a familiar chairman
There is an irony here that is difficult to ignore. Before his arrival at Watford, Duxbury’s career at West Ham United had been shadowed by one of English football’s most notorious disputes over player ownership. Carlos Tevez and Javier Mascherano arrived at West Ham in 2006 amid third-party contractual arrangements. In 2007 the Premier League fined West Ham £5.5 million for breaches of its rules. Tevez then helped the club survive on the final day, while Sheffield United went down and pursued compensation. An out-of-court settlement followed in 2009. The affair helped establish why English football came to prohibit third-party ownership of players’ economic rights.
Duxbury was West Ham’s chief executive during the latter stages of the controversy and was criticised in the ensuing proceedings. He denied wrongdoing. He resigned in January 2010 after David Gold and David Sullivan took over the club and installed Karren Brady in a senior role. It would be wrong to say he was formally sacked over Tevez; it would be just as misleading to suggest his West Ham chapter ended amid universal applause. That is enough history for our purposes. This is not a fresh investigation of Duxbury’s conduct seventeen years ago.
What makes the echo so striking is the recurring question about the separation of a football club from the economic interests of those who finance, manage or hold rights connected to its players. The West Ham dispute and Operation Líbero involve different transactions, different rules, different jurisdictions and different allegations. They are not the same case. But for a supporter looking at the long arc of Duxbury’s career, there is a grim circularity to seeing a Watford project already diminished by years of sporting and managerial instability face yet another potential shadow: legal proceedings involving the owner with whom Duxbury has been so closely associated.
When a player belongs to the club — and the profit does not
The Spanish prosecution alleges that financial arrangements involving Granada and companies including Fifteen Securitisation diverted or mischaracterised proceeds from player trading and resulted in unpaid corporation tax. Tax agency experts have questioned whether particular decisions were in Granada’s interests. Defence witnesses and experts have challenged the interpretation, arguing that the contracts and transactions were genuine and commercially explicable. Gino Pozzo and the other defendants contest the allegations. The judges, not supporters or journalists, must decide the criminal issues.
Yet there is a football question here which survives regardless of the eventual verdict: what does it mean for a club if the upside from developing and selling footballers may sit somewhere other than the club itself? A structure can provide much-needed finance and distribute risk. It can also make it harder for supporters to work out who benefits from a successful transfer and who is left carrying the cost when a deal disappoints. Those possibilities are precisely why the details matter.
English rules changed after Tevez, and third-party ownership of players’ economic rights was prohibited. That makes it especially important not to transplant the Spanish allegations wholesale onto Watford. We have no verified basis to claim that the particular arrangements alleged at Granada were used here. The legitimate question is a counterfactual one: if the rules had permitted comparable arrangements in England, would they have been attractive to those managing a multi-club football business? We cannot know the answer. But asking how regulatory differences shape financial behaviour is not the same as alleging a breach of the rules.
A fee undisclosed. A question unanswered.
Watford supporters do not need a Spanish criminal trial to tell them that understanding the club’s finances can be frustrating. Years of transfers described as being for an ‘undisclosed fee’ have made it difficult to trace the real economics of recruitment and sales. That description is common across English football and is not, in itself, evidence of anything improper. Nevertheless, repeated opacity becomes part of the atmosphere in which trust is either built or steadily worn away.
It is possible for a club to comply with disclosure rules and still leave its supporters with a very incomplete picture. Headline accounts tell one story; the practical relationships between owners, associated clubs, intermediaries, lenders and recruitment decisions can tell another. If an incoming player has moved through several connected organisations, supporters are entitled to ask who agreed the valuation, who bore the risk, and whether the transaction was principally designed to improve their football club.
None of this is a demand for every negotiating position or commercially sensitive detail to be broadcast from the Rookery. It is a demand for something less exotic: an intelligible explanation of how the club is financed, what obligations it carries, and how the people in charge resolve competing interests. ‘Trust us’ is not a financial statement, however often it is repeated.
Whose football club is it anyway?
A football club is an unusual business. It can be bought and sold, it can owe money, it can trade assets and it can be part of a wider international network. But it also belongs, in a different and enduring sense, to the community that supports it. The owner can leave. The supporters generally cannot. That imbalance is why questions about conflicts of interest matter even when nobody has been convicted of anything.
The Pozzo network demonstrated how shared scouting, recruitment and player movement might offer smaller clubs access to opportunities they could never create alone. It also made Watford part of an ecosystem in which the interests of different clubs were not always necessarily identical. A move that benefits one member of the network might be less obviously advantageous to another. That is not proof of bad faith. It is an inherent tension in multi-club ownership, and one which requires strong governance and credible scrutiny rather than assurances alone.
At Granada, the Spanish court is hearing evidence about what decisions were made, by whom and for whose benefit. At Watford, the challenge is to insist on clearer answers about the present and future without pretending that we already know what the judges in Madrid will conclude. We can remember the joy of promotion and still question the financial model. We can be grateful for a cup final and still ask who ultimately profits from a transfer. Supporting a club has never required suspending the ability to count.
The trial continues. So does the responsibility to ask.
Operation Líbero is scheduled to resume at the Audiencia Nacional on Monday 16 November, with defendants expected to give evidence. Their accounts will matter. So will the defence case, the prosecution’s response and the court’s eventual findings. The alleged tax offences concern Granada’s historical operations, and all defendants remain entitled to the presumption of innocence. Nothing in this article should be mistaken for a claim that criminal wrongdoing has been established at Watford.
The more immediate risk for the Hornets is not that the events in Spain somehow rewrite the result of a match at Vicarage Road. It is that a club already living with questions about its finances, direction and relationship with its supporters may find those questions sharpened by the public scrutiny of its owner. A reputation built during the good years can be eroded by a long sequence of explanations that never quite arrive.
If the court ultimately rejects the allegations, Watford supporters will still be entitled to transparency. If the court upholds them, the implications will need to be assessed on the actual judgment, not on the most alarming headline. Either way, we should resist two temptations: declaring guilt in advance, and treating the entire business as somebody else’s problem. There but for the grace of God go we. The sensible response is not to look away.
Reporting and background
This is an opinion article drawing on contemporary reporting and historical accounts. The Tevez affair and the allegations in Operation Líbero are distinct matters. No wrongdoing at Watford is alleged or established by this article.
BBC Sport — Tevez affair and third-party ownership
BBC Sport — Carlos Tevez at West Ham
The Independent — Duxbury resigns from West Ham, January 2010
The Guardian — Duxbury and the Tevez tribunal, January 2009
Granada Hoy — expert evidence, 12 November 2026
Ahora Granada — tax experts’ evidence, 12 November 2026
AS — the prosecution allegations and defence position
Sky Sports — Duxbury’s commitment to Rob Edwards and the September 2022 dismissal