Who decides Gino Pozzo's fate? A DNSYE legal explainer on Operation Líbero and Spain's Audiencia Nacional.
THE WATFORD JOURNAL
Friday, 13 November 2026
No jury, no magistrates in the British sense, and potentially a much shorter interval between the end of the trial and the announcement of any punishment.
OPERATION LÍBERO · LEGAL EXPLAINER

Who decides Gino Pozzo’s fate?

The Operation Líbero trial at Spain’s Audiencia Nacional has now completed its first three days of evidence. Gino Pozzo, Quique Pina and their fellow defendants are due back in court on Monday, when their own testimony is expected to begin.

For British observers, the proceedings raise two important questions. Who actually decides whether the defendants are guilty, and how long might it take before the court announces its decision?

The answers reveal some significant differences between Spanish criminal justice and the system familiar to football supporters in England and Wales.

THE THREE JUDGES

Spain’s alternative to a jury

Operation Líbero is being heard by a professional judicial panel, not a jury.

Operation Líbero is being heard by the Second Section of the Criminal Chamber of Spain’s Audiencia Nacional. Although that sounds rather grand, the explanation is straightforward. The Audiencia Nacional is a national court dealing with certain serious and complex cases, its Criminal Chamber handles criminal proceedings, and that chamber is divided into four sections to distribute its workload.

The Second Section is therefore not a separate level of justice or an appeal court. It is simply one of the divisions responsible for hearing criminal cases. Each section has several professional judges, but individual trials are ordinarily heard by a panel of three. Those three judges, rather than a jury, decide whether the defendants are guilty and what punishment, if any, should follow.

One judge presides over the hearing and another acts as the reporting judge, or ponente, responsible for preparing the judgment.

The judges consider the evidence, decide whether the prosecution has proved each defendant’s guilt and determine the penalties if anyone is convicted. Decisions are made by majority vote. Unlike a British jury, the judges must explain their reasoning in a written judgment.

THE BRITISH COMPARISON

How does that compare with England and Wales?

Magistrates’ Court: magistrates or a district judge decide guilt and determine sentence.

Crown Court jury trial: usually 12 jurors decide guilt, while the judge determines sentence.

Spanish Audiencia Nacional: a professional judicial panel, ordinarily three judges, decides guilt and determines any sentence.

The nearest British comparison is a Crown Court trial, but imagine replacing the jury with three legally qualified judges who both decide guilt and, if necessary, sentence the defendants.

That is not because the Spanish system regards financial offences as less serious. Spain does have jury trials, but their use is restricted to specified offences. Complex tax-fraud proceedings of this kind are ordinarily decided by professional judges.

There is another important distinction: although England and Wales also have legally qualified district judges sitting alone in Magistrates’ Courts, Spanish magistrados in the Audiencia Nacional are senior professional judges. They are not equivalent to Britain’s volunteer lay magistrates.

THE TIMETABLE

When could we expect the judgment?

Monday 16 November — defendants’ evidence. Gino Pozzo, Quique Pina, Raffaele de la Riva and Jordi Trilles are expected to testify from 10am Spanish time.

Final submissions — date unconfirmed. Once the evidence is complete, the parties must have the opportunity to make their final submissions. The defendants can also exercise their right to a final statement.

Judgment — potentially shortly afterwards. If the abbreviated criminal procedure applies, Article 789 requires judgment within five days of the oral trial’s conclusion.

This five-day provision is not speculation. It appears expressly in Spain’s criminal procedure legislation.

The remaining uncertainty is whether the case is formally being heard under the procedimiento abreviado. That appears consistent with the charges and the court’s jurisdiction, but the relevant procedural order has not yet been obtained.

The five days are a statutory deadline, not a promise that a complex judgment will necessarily be delivered on time. Nor does the clock start when the defendants finish their testimony: it starts when the entire oral trial is formally concluded.

THE POSSIBLE OUTCOMES

One verdict, potentially several different outcomes

Unlike the familiar English Crown Court sequence, where a jury delivers its verdict and a judge may then adjourn for sentencing reports and a separate hearing, the Spanish court would ordinarily announce its findings and any punishment in the same written sentencia.

That judgment must address each defendant individually. It is entirely possible for the panel to reach different conclusions about Pozzo, Pina, Riva, Trilles and Granada CF as a corporate defendant.

Acquittal, conviction, imprisonment, financial penalties and corporate sanctions are all matters governed by the particular charges and applicable law. The fact that prosecutors seek a penalty does not mean the judges will impose it.

The prosecution alleges that financial structures involving Granada, Fifteen Securitisation and other companies were used to avoid Spanish corporation tax. The defendants deny criminal wrongdoing, and defence experts have argued that the transactions were genuine, documented commercial arrangements.

Even after a conviction, a sentence would not necessarily be final. Appeals could follow, and the question of whether any prison term would actually be served involves further legal considerations.

THE JOURNAL’S CONCLUSION

The milestone that matters

The interesting prospect is that Operation Líbero could move from a decade-long investigation to a written criminal judgment relatively quickly once the final hearing concludes.

But we cannot yet put a reliable date on that judgment. The court has not publicly confirmed the complete remaining hearing timetable in the sources examined, and the formal procedural classification still needs documentary confirmation.

For Monday, there are three developments worth watching: what the defendants say under questioning, whether the court announces any further hearing dates, and whether final submissions are scheduled.

The phrase that matters most is visto para sentencia — the point at which the court declares that the case is ready for judgment.

That, rather than Monday’s appearance alone, is the milestone from which we can begin assessing the likely judgment date.

MINI SOURCE DESK

Sources

Granada Hoy — Third day of the trial
12 November 2026, 13:36 Spanish time. Courtroom reporting on prosecution and defence experts and the next hearing.

Ahora Granada — Trial procedure and witnesses
10 November 2026. Details from the prosecution documents and the court’s planned evidence.

Spanish Criminal Procedure Act — official legislation
Articles 149–153, 757, 788 and 789: judicial deliberation, abbreviated procedure, final submissions and judgment deadlines.

Audiencia Nacional — official annual report
Institutional information on the Criminal Chamber and its Second Section. This does not identify the specific trial panel.